I have finally gotten around to writing about my 5 favorite albums of the last 30 years. My biggest motivation in publishing this list is to hear everyone else's personal list. I'd love to read about which albums you consider your favorites.
5. Guided By Voices- Bee Thousand- Lead singer and writer Robert Pollard was a school teacher who led Guided By Voices on the side. Since teachers can’t afford high production values when recording their music masterpieces, Bee Thousand sounds as if it was recorded directly onto a tape recorder. When a group has songs as catchy as these, there is no need for studio trickery. Bee Thousand consists of 20 songs in less than 40 minutes. In the tradition of Wire’s Pink Flag and The Minutemen’s Double Nickels on the Dime, musical ideas never overstay their welcome with extended guitar solos or extraneous verses. The Goldheart Mountaintop Queen Directory is the quitessential song on this album. It’s hard to imagine a song whose chorus hinges on this oddly name title to be as touching as it is. The lyrics don’t matter. It’s the passion behind the delivery and the insanely addicting melody that make me play the song on repeat almost every time.
4. The Strokes- Is This It?
I was hooked on The Strokes well before their hyped debut was released in America. What I heard was a modern version of The Velvet Underground. The Strokes weren’t doing anything original. Any hope that they’d be the saviors of rock was based on fantasy for that very reason. Julian Casablancas’ vocals perfected Lou Reed’s disaffected New York cool attitude. The guitars chugged along with a rhythm section that echoed Velvet Underground circa Sister Ray. My hope wasn’t that The Strokes would save rock music. I just wanted them to be popular enough for people to discover VU. I used to walk into Hot Topic every month or so to check if they were selling Velvet Underground t-shirts thanks to The Strokes’ popularity. Listening to Is This It now is similar to listening to Nirvana’s Nevermind. After all the hype is gone, what we’re left with is a great rock record. The Strokes didn’t want to change the world. They just wanted to make great rock music that echoed their greatest influence. Mission accomplished.
3. Jay-Z- The Blueprint
The blueprint for The Blueprint was simple; the best rapper in the world rapping for 14 songs with only one guest musician. I don’t understand why great rap artists don’t stick to this formula more often. The common problem with most rap albums are that they’re stretched too long, contain pointless interludes and skits that break up the momentum, and feature so many guest artists to the point where you forget whose album you’re actually listening to. The Blueprint was Jay-Z’s victory album. My favorite moment on the album is on “Heart Of The City” when he says “I told you in ’96 that I came to take this shit and I did” as the horns behind him reach a peak. This is the sound of an artist who has reached the mountain top and has earned his right to celebrate. Of course, this alone wouldn’t make The Blueprint a great album. The quality of all rap albums depends on the beats, and The Blueprint is where Kanye West first achieved his greatness. It’s almost impossible to talk about The Blueprint without mentioning the greatest diss track ever, The Takeover. It’s worth researching Nas’s career just to appreciate how jay-Z puts him down by using simple math.
2. Beck-Odelay
I’ve never been obsessed with an album more than I was with Odelay during my freshman year in high school. I’ll make two points that may sound blasphemous.
1. I always think of Odelay as this era’s Revolver for the way the album blends different styles so effortlessly. Country-rock, rap, 60s psychedelic, hard rock are all blended to create an incredible kaleidoscope of sound. Musicians have tried this before, but it’s rare when it sounds so natural.
2. Beck channels the wild, absurdist imagery of Bob Dylan’s mid 60s heyday better than any musician. My personal favorite example is “Driving my pig while the bear’s taking pictures in the grass”. It’s a throwback to lines such as Dylan’s “The sun’s not yellow. It’s chicken!” It makes no literal sense, but that’s not the point. Beck is a lyrical master on Odelay. I also love the attack of assonance he has when he sings about the “Chain-smoke Kansas flashdance ass-pants.” I know some people, including Beck’s girlfriend at the time, complained that there was no emotional value to these lyrics. Beck wasn’t shooting for the Kleenex with these lyrics. To paraphrase the man himself, this is the album he got crazy with the cheese-whiz.
1. Pavement- Slanted and Enchanted
I think I’ve finally come to grips with the fact that Pavement isn’t for everyone. Stephen Malkmus isn’t technically a good singer, the guitars aren’t always in tune, and the drummer on Slanted and Enchanted was unimpressive enough that the band soon got rid of him. It’s easy to initially dismiss this record for all the reasons stated above. But what lies beneath are the some of the most beautiful melodies committed to record. Behind those distorted guitars and laconic vocals are gorgeous, un-ironic “sha-la-la” chants and melodic hooks reminiscent of singer-songwriters of the 70s.
Pavement is known for starting the lo-fi movement in indie rock. Part of the album’s charm is that it does not have the streamlined production of your average record. There’s a great murky, mysterious quality to Slanted and Enchanted. When I bought the album, I had only seen one photograph of the band. The cd booklet featured cryptic messages, lyrics to a few selected songs, and most powerfully no pictures of the band. The two main forces in the band weren’t even mentioned by their actual names. They were listed as “S.M.” and “Spiral Staircase”. It all contributed to the strange feeling of listening to this album for the first time. But once you dig past that intimidating surface, there is a world of gold underneath. It’s the discovery that’s half the fun.
Saturday, February 20, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Somehow I feel I have been referenced in your introductory statement regarding Pavement. I will finish listening to their "greatest hits" and give you my favorites and reasons. We have already discussed at length where you and I differ when it comes to music vs. lyrics vs. sound. I'll give these guys a try if it means I can contribute more to lunch discussions!
ReplyDeletePS... let's get a list of Best Movie soundtracks on here!
ReplyDeleteBesides The Strokes, I haven't listened to any of these! I'll start thinking of mine. I like the Movie Soundtracks idea Kelly. That'll be next!
ReplyDeleteI too will be working on my list - I have different reasons for liking certain soundtracks though. Just because the soundtrack is good doesn't mean the movie was (or vice versa) - but the general compilation of the soundtrack is what I will use to guide my list creation (if I'm going to get into this, then I have to be organized!).
ReplyDeleteSoundtracks haven't been a big part of my listening experience. But I like the question of what makes a good soundtrack? I think a great soundtrack does something more than take a random collection of great songs and put it one place.
ReplyDeleteSee I think they fall into one of two categories. I like movies like Casablanca, Breakfast @ Tiffany's, and The Graduate because their soundtracks are really apart of the movie experience. Played over and over either by the characters or in the background - the same songs/artists are repeated. You can't listen to "Moon River" and not think of Breakfast @ Tiffany's (unless of course you haven't seen it at all). Then there are the soundtracks that just go with the moment/scene. Those are your more random compilations but when put together with the context of the movie - work nicely. I will continue to ponder my list...
ReplyDeletePart 1 - 11-25
ReplyDelete11. Kanye West – “The College Dropout” – Just a great, smart, fun album, with songs that never get old for me.
12. Hootie & The Blowfish – “Cracked Rear View” – Not loved by critics, this is one of those “millions of people can’t be wrong” albums. Count me as one of those millions. Darius Rucker’s voice is so good he can churn out #1 country albums now. I probably overrate this album a bit based on the time of my life I was devouring it (Ricarda was in Florida, my first year commuting to NYC, etc.)
13. Ben Folds Five – “Ben Folds Five” – Their first 2 albums blend together as a collection of smart, melodic songs. I cheat a little here by leaving off “Whatever & Ever Amen” and placing this album here to represent them both.
14. Skid Row – “Slave to the Grind” – This album might represent the peak of “cheese metal”, remembering it hit #1 on the Billboard album chart. It’s hard to take Sebastian Bach seriously, but his voice was amazing.
15. Jay-Z – “Blueprint” – Mitch’s comments said it best. I’ll just add “Ditto”
16. Soul Asylum – “Grave Dancers Union” – A great 2 album stretch from a band I thought (and hoped) would have lasted longer.
17. Alanis Morissette – “Jagged Little Pill” – Despite the fact “Ironic” featured very little irony, what is ironic is that overall; this was still one of the most well-written albums of the ‘90’s.
18. Tesla – “Bust A Nut” – I have always claimed they were the #1 “victims”, in terms of groups labeled as “cheese metal” b/c of the era they gained fame…. But I can’t even count the times I’ve heard those exact sentiments echoed by others when songs pop up on the radio. (Side note: “5 Man Acoustical Jam” is disqualified from this list b/c it’s arguably a greatest hits album. If allowed, it would have been #1)
19. Gavin DeGraw – “Chariot” – I’m sure I would have never been a fan had I not seen him live as an opening act before this album got airplay. It’s rare to hear a singer perform without knowing any songs, and like them right away.
20. Weezer – “Weezer” – One of the most appreciated bands around, in terms of longevity.
21. Third Eye Blind – “Third Eye Blind” – Another great album from start to finish.
22. Stroke 9 – “Nasty Little Thoughts” – Just a fun album from start to finish. An example of one of those albums I would never discover in today’s iTunes world of buying singles instead of albums.
23. The White Stripes – “Icky Thump” – The #1 group on this list I’ve never seen live and want to. Jack White is already a legend.
24. Badlands – “Voodoo Highway” – The most talented lead singer (Ray Gillen, RIP), lead guitar (Jake E. Lee) rock combo on this list. Plus this album led to my favorite (and most shocking) AI performance ever, when Bo Bice covered “In A Dream”.
25. Marc Broussard – “Carencro” – My favorite “never made it big” album ever. A great singer who just needed to be heard live to appreciate. Got a standing ovation (the only one) at a Billboard function that featured various artists, all with more notoriety.
Part II
ReplyDeleteMy Top 25 Albums since 1990
Mitch… You Asked For It, You Got It…” I’ll start this list by admitting much of this list can not be defended. This is a far cry from a “critically acclaimed” list. It just represents albums I continue to find myself going back to, even after thinking I wore them out when they were released. Side notes: By eliminating all albums before the ‘90’s, I thought this list would be easy to compile. I didn’t realize how many great albums by artists/bands like Ben Folds Five, The White Stripes, Kanye West, Pearl Jam, Outkast, etc. didn’t make the cut, even after I expanded this to 25 albums. I also left the comments brief. Mitch – this is something you’re much better at than I.
1. Pete Yorn – “musicforthemorningafter” – I can say with a fair amount of certainty, this is a controversial choice. Still, I have never enjoyed an album from start to finish more than this one, and I guess that trumps everything else.
2. Nirvana – “Nevermind” – I’m almost embarrassed not listing this as #1. Besides the fact it changed the course of music forever, at the time of it’s release I loved it as much as any one I knew. I’m still bummed I never had the chance to see them live.
3. The Refreshments – “Fizzy Fuzzy Big & Buzzy” – The epitome of the list, in terms of my listing albums I love. This album is simply best described as FUN.
4. Weezer – “Pinkerton” – I was late to the party on this one. Probably the most underappreciated rock album ever, from an albums sold standpoint (especially considering how mainstream Weezer became). Still funny to think how this album was panned by critics initially.
5. Matchbox 20 – “Yourself or Someone Like You” – I bought this album after the first single was released, and played it more than any other, and yet I always find myself coming back to it. I’m glad to see Rob Thomas is still going strong.
6. Live – “Mental Jewelry” – The album before they hit it big. Another album featuring songs I will never grow tired of. It’s just too bad they stopped recording albums nearly as good after their first two.
7. Pearl Jam – “Ten” – This album followed “Nevermind” as the knock-out punch to end the cheese metal era. I’m still upset this happened, but at least it was done by a deserving duo.
8. Seven Mary Three – “American Standard” – Great memories of playing (or as I would like to say “dominating”) NHL ’94 with this on in the background. Plus without this album, the classic “Seven Mary 3!!!” concert memory would have never have entered my life.
9. Foo Fighters – “The Colour and the Shape” – Their first album was just a warm up for this classic. It sealed Dave Grohl’s ticket into the Rock N Roll Hall of Fame.
10. Arctic Monkeys – “Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I’m Not” – At least for me, one of those rare times an album lives up to the overseas hype.
I'm surprised Icky Thump is your favorite White Stripes cd. I'm glad to have introduced Pinkerton to you. It's pretty amazing to think about the career Dave Grohl has had.
ReplyDelete